You Have Kids, Right?
You might be interested to note that the McCain McEducation McPlan is full of McShit. You might also be interested in those cookies you have hidden in the cabinet from the children, but stop thinking about that for a moment. They won’t spoil in the time it takes to read about the vague outline of McCain’s plan for education.
Feel free to go here to read about it. My comment got so long that I realized it would be a post unto itself:
It is so past the time when politicians make enormous decisions regarding education that I feel almost silly saying it again: ask teachers.
Teachers will tell you that:
1. Whoever gets to measure the arbitrary goal of “potential” doesn’t truly understand the growth of a child. What does that really look like and what does it truly mean? I fear that standards are applied differently to different groups and this is too vague an exploration as you’ve posted here.
2. If all schools were equalized parents wouldn’t need more choices. This usually serves to allow wealthier parents to choose entitled schooling for their children and is a classic case of the rich getting richer.
3. “Quality teachers” doesn’t take into account some of the most important qualities of educators. In my experience teachers who graduate in the top of their class aren’t the best teachers. The best teachers are the ones who CARE about the students. Can you ensure that those “top grades” college students will actually care more about children?
4. Putting technology into schools requires training teachers FIRST. He wants technological development for virtual schools? Are you going to pull from those “top graduates” with the “top grades” once again? This, to me, doesn’t seem to help the issue of students simply not reading at grade level. It appears to be one more way to divide the haves and have-nots. Those math and science academies serve to stimulate students who do well in those courses, but, again, it takes students away from schools that then become ’struggling schools’.
Nothing is mentioned about early childhood programs focusing on literacy and numeracy or helping high school students and their families access higher education. That is part of the reason real reform continues to fail the masses: real reform isn’t FOR the masses.
Meaningful reform comes from taking the lead from the true leaders. No one ever asks them in a format that brings about true change and educators keep on working to meet impossible standards (how is it again that we’re responsible for their attendance when we get no support from state and local agencies to enforce this?) and do the work that no one else is willing to do or even be responsible for when it fails.


